Brewers vs. Cardinals Odds & Betting Predictions - May 5, 2026

Brewers at Cardinals

11:45 pm • BREW
@
Starting Pitchers
pitcherteameraw-l
Andre Pallante logoA.PallanteSt. Louis Cardinals logo3.733-2
Brandon Sproat logoB.SproatMilwaukee Brewers logo6.750-2

Brewers at Cardinals Odds

Spread, Total, Moneyline

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Brewers
18-16
PK
-1.5+159
o7.5-116
-110
Cardinals
21-14
u7.5
+1.5-183
u7.5-104
-110
location pinTuesday 11:45 p.m.
May 05, 2026
Busch StadiumSt. Louis
thermometer image49°Fahrenheit
rain image73%Rain
wind image10Wind
Brewers vs. Cardinals Expert Picks
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Payoff Pitch Podcast
Last 30d: 81-99-10 (+17.5u)
A.Pallante u3.5 Ks+125
0.5u
@cowhitchurch ⭐️⭐️ https://myaction.app/JSRRLRwFT2b
Under 8-110
0.5u
@Zerillo ⭐️⭐️ https://myaction.app/JSRRLRwFT2b
Frank Ammirante
Frank Ammirante
Last 30d: 313-327-12 (+1.1u)
Under 8-112
1.12u
Top Shelf Action 🥃
Top Shelf Action 🥃
Last 30d: 258-287-14 (+23.0u)
A.Burleson To Hit 1+ Home Runs Yes+825
0.05u
#EV 7.2%
B.Sproat o4.5 Hits Allowed-110
0.76u
#EV 5.56%
I.Herrera To Hit 1+ Home Runs Yes+1000
0.1u
#EV 16.2%
Ryan Minion
Ryan Minion
Last 30d: 288-356-11 (-12.6u)
J.Walker o1.5 Total Bases+125
$1.00
J.Chourio o1.5 Total Bases+107
$1.00
Brian Bitler
Brian Bitler
Last 30d: 95-86-0 (+43.3u)
MIL +102
3u
RoyalsProps
RoyalsProps
Last 30d: 78-45-8 (+29.4u)
B.Turang o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs-113
1.13u
J.Wetherholt o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs-115
1.15u
Sean Zerillo
Sean Zerillo
Last 30d: 154-147-15 (-7.1u)
Under 8-110
0.55u
Bet to 7.5 (-107)
Cam Is Money
Cam Is Money
Last 30d: 117-142-2 (-24.4u)
Over 8-107
2u
Doug Ziefel
Doug Ziefel
Last 30d: 222-242-8 (-10.8u)
MIL -105
0.53u

Brewers vs. Cardinals Previews & Analysis

  • Brewers vs Cardinals: Zerillo's Projection for Tuesday article feature image

    Brewers vs Cardinals: Zerillo's Projection for Tuesday

    Sean Zerillo
    May 5, 2026 UTC
  • Adam Trigger's Triple-A Picks For Tuesday article feature image

    Adam Trigger's Triple-A Picks For Tuesday

    Adam Trigger
    May 5, 2026 UTC
See more MLB Coverage Right Arrow

Prop Odds Comparison

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

No props found

Line Movement Tracker

Right Arrow
Right Arrow

Brewers vs. Cardinals Public Betting Percentages

Away Logo

Brewers

Public

36%

Bets%

64%

Money%

Matchup History

Against the Spread (ATS) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Cardinals
23-1212-711-51-122-11
Brewers
20-1410-810-612-98-5

Over/Under History

overallhome o/uaway o/ufavorite o/uunderdog o/u
Cardinals
18-15-29-9-19-6-11-117-14-2
Brewers
17-16-110-87-8-111-9-16-7

Straight-Up (ML) History

overallhomeawayfavoriteunderdog
Cardinals
21-1410-911-51-120-13
Brewers
18-1610-88-812-96-7

Last 5 Matchups

dateopponentscorespreadover/undermoneyline
May 4thMILW 6-3+1.5 WU 9STL +100
May 3rdLADL 1-4+1.5 LU 9.5LAD +118
May 2ndLADW 3-2+1.5 WU 9STL +109
May 2ndLADW 7-2+1.5 WO 8.5STL +145
Apr 30th@PITW 10-5+1.5 WO 7STL +205

Cardinals vs. Brewers Injury Updates

Cardinals Injuries

  • Lars Nootbaar
    LF

    Nootbaar is out with heel

    Out

Brewers Injuries

  • Akil Baddoo
    LF

    Baddoo is out with quad

    Out

  • Quinn Priester
    SP

    Priester is out with wrist

    Out

Brewers vs. Cardinals Starting Lineups
Brewers Starting Lineup
Projected
PITCHERW-LERAWHIPK/9
Brandon Sproat logoRB.Sproat, P0-26.751.6138.44
HITTERSAVGOBPSLGHR
Garrett Mitchell logo1G.Mitchell, CF.219.364.3331
Jackson Chourio logo2J.Chourio, LF1.0001.000.5000
Brice Turang logo3B.Turang, 2B.304.434.5225
William Contreras logo4W.Contreras, C.295.364.4193
Jake Bauers logo5J.Bauers, 1B.248.325.4345
Andrew Vaughn logo6A.Vaughn, DH.125.222.1250
Sal Frelick logo7S.Frelick, RF.212.311.3173
Luis Rengifo logo8L.Rengifo, 3B.188.252.2670
David Hamilton logo9D.Hamilton, SS.235.337.2590
Cardinals Starting Lineup
Projected
PITCHERW-LERAWHIPK/9
Andre Pallante logoRA.Pallante, P3-23.731.3087.47
HITTERSAVGOBPSLGHR
JJ Wetherholt logo1J.Wetherholt, 2B.246.360.4407
Ivan Herrera logo2I.Herrera, DH.256.416.4244
Alec Burleson logo3A.Burleson, 1B.269.349.4485
Jordan Walker logo4J.Walker, RF.308.377.58510
Nolan Gorman logo5N.Gorman, 3B.224.285.3795
Masyn Winn logo6M.Winn, SS.274.357.3721
Nathan Church logo7N.Church, LF.248.278.4365
Pedro Pages logo8P.Pages, C.237.289.3953
Victor Scott logo9V.Scott, CF.184.250.2411

Brewers vs. Cardinals Odds Comparison

Right Arrow

Could not load odds

Brewers at Cardinals Team Totals

MatchupOverUnder
Brewers
18-16
N/A
N/A
Cardinals
21-14
N/A
N/A