Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds & Betting Predictions - May 19, 2026

Blue Jays at Yankees

11:05 pm • YES

Toronto Blue Jays

39-39

4 - 5

New York Yankees

46-31

pitcher		team	era	w-l
W.Warren			3.45	7-2
D.Cease			2.75	4-3

MatchupOpenSpreadTotalMoneyline
Blue Jays 39-39	+1.5	+1.5-183	o8.5-120	+112
Yankees 46-31	u8.5	-1.5+153	u8.5+100	-134

Tuesday 11:05 p.m.

May 19, 2026

Yankee StadiumBronx

TOR +120

Join Discord for earlier access: https://discord.gg/HjKxYKdSUy Toronto is 7-3 over its last 10 while New York is 3-7 in the same window. Cease owns a 2.41 ERA with 1 HR allowed in 52.1 innings, which plays in this park. At +120, I am taking the hotter dog with the better run-prevention starter.

W.Warren o16.5 Outs-135

1.35u

D.Varsho o0.5 HR+425

0.5u

@gneiffer07 ⭐️⭐️ https://myaction.app/kqUcW4tTg3b

Under 0.5 (1st Inn)+100

V.Guerrero o1.5 Hits + Runs + RBIs-130

1.3u

D.Varsho o0.5 HR+425

0.25u

D.Cease u7.5 Ks-112

1.12u

Under 9-115

0.58u

Bet to -125

Under 9-115

0.58u

(B365) Adding with better line.

Under 8.5-102

0.51u

(DK) See Tuesday's article (Good to -115)

Blue Jays vs Yankees: Elite Starters Set the Pace
Matt Trollo•
May 19, 2026 UTC
Our 5 MLB Best Bets for Tuesday Night
Action Network Staff•
May 19, 2026 UTC
Grant Neiffer's 4 Home Run Picks for Tuesday
Grant Neiffer•
May 19, 2026 UTC
Adam Trigger's Triple-A Picks for Tuesday, Including an 11 AM Matchup
Adam Trigger•
May 19, 2026 UTC

See more MLB Coverage

No props found

MLB Public Betting

Yankees are 1-4 in their last 5 games.
Yankees are 1-4 in their last 5 games against the spread
Yankees are 20-20 in their road games against the spread
The totals have gone OVER in 1 of Yankees' last 5 games
The totals have gone OVER in 19 of Yankees' 37 last games at home

Against the Spread (ATS) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Yankees	37-40	17-20	20-20	34-36	3-4
Blue Jays	38-40	20-20	18-20	21-20	16-20

Over/Under History

	overall	home o/u	away o/u	favorite o/u	underdog o/u
Yankees	35-38-4	19-16-2	16-22-2	30-36-4	5-2
Blue Jays	38-37-3	21-18-1	17-19-2	21-18-2	16-19-1

Straight-Up (ML) History

	overall	home	away	favorite	underdog
Yankees	46-31	22-15	24-16	42-28	4-3
Blue Jays	39-39	22-18	17-21	24-17	14-22

date	opponent	score	spread	over/under	moneyline
May 18th	TOR	W 7-6	-1.5 L	O 9	NYY -172
May 17th	@NYM	L 6-7	-1.5 L	O 9	NYM +105
May 16th	@NYM	L 3-6	-1.5 L	O 8.5	NYM -125
May 15th	@NYM	W 5-2	-1.5 W	U 7	NYY -147
May 13th	@BAL	L 0-7	-1.5 L	U 8.5	BAL -164

Jose Berrios
SP
Berrios is out with elbow
Out
Anthony Santander
RF
Santander is out with shoulder
Out
Bowden Francis
SP
Francis is out with shoulder
Out
Addison Barger
RF
Addison Barger (elbow) scratched Sunday.
Out

Clarke Schmidt
SP
Schmidt is out with elbow
Out

See more MLB Injuries

PITCHER	PC	IP	K	ER
RD.Cease, P	100	5	9	5
LA.Macko, P	14	0.2	1	0
RC.Lee, P	13	0.1	0	0
LM.Fluharty, P	9	1	1	0
RL.Varland, P	6	1	1	0

HITTERS	H-AB	R	RBI
1G.Springer, DH	1-5	0	0
2V.Guerrero, 1B	0-3	0	1
3D.Varsho, CF	4-5	1	0
4K.Okamoto, 3B	0-4	1	0
5Y.Pinango, LF	1-3	1	1
5M.Straw, PH	0-1	0	0
5M.Straw, RF	0-1	0	0
6J.Sanchez, RF	1-3	0	1
6L.Sosa, PH	0-1	0	0
6L.Sosa, 2B	0-1	0	0
7D.Schneider, 2B	0-2	0	0
7D.Schneider, LF	0-2	0	0
8A.Gimenez, SS	1-3	1	1
9T.Heineman, C	0-3	0	0
9E.Clement, PH	1-1	0	0

PITCHER	PC	IP	K	ER
RW.Warren, P	86	5	3	3
LT.Hill, P	17	1	1	0
RJ.Bird, P	11	0.2	1	0
LB.Headrick, P	24	1.1	2	0
RC.Doval, P	22	1	0	1

HITTERS	H-AB	R	HR	RBI
1T.Grisham, CF	1-3	1	0	0
2B.Rice, 1B	1-4	1	1	2
3A.Judge, RF	0-3	1	0	0
4C.Bellinger, LF	1-3	0	0	0
5J.Chisholm, 2B	0-3	1	0	0
6R.McMahon, 3B	2-4	1	1	3
7A.Volpe, SS	1-4	0	0	0
8S.Jones, DH	0-2	0	0	0
8P.Goldschmidt, PH	0-1	0	0	0
8P.Goldschmidt, DH	0-1	0	0	0
9A.Wells, C	0-2	0	0	0